Marco Polo Pizzerias

Reviews

• Mike Finch

  star star star star star 6 June 2026

  This pizzeria has been around for 30 years. I ate there regularly when I lived in Bohemia. Now, I will drive from Amityville for a slice. It's that good. Consistently hot, fresh, just the right crispness in the crust while still being chewy. It's the perfect slice, no question.

• James Vicino

  star star star star star 28 May 2026

  This place has the best garlic knots! Everything else is delicious too. Always great service. Did mention awesome garlic knots?

• Kimberly Franco

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 20 May 2026

  If I could give no stars, I would. The service from the older gentleman that I just witnessed happening to another customer in their business was disgusting. I stop in a few times here & there to get a couple of slices on my back to work on my lunch break. I have never had a problem with the customer service that I get because I tend to deal with the younger gentleman behind the counter. The older gentleman who was behind the counter today was disgustingly rude to another customer because one of their employees got an order wrong. She ordered chicken cutlet entrée with a salad and they made chicken parmigiana with a salad. The woman even stated that she wasn't sure, she just ordered what another person wanted, she even pointed it out on their menu. He was so belittling to her and his attitude towards her was disgusting, he kept yelling at her and telling her what was in the chicken parmigiana to which the woman stated that she didn't know what was in it but all she wanted was the chicken cutlet that they had on their menu. He then took back the box with the rest of her food & threw it back on the counter and told her that she would have to wait 25 minutes then. If you cannot work with customers, then you shouldn't be working with customers. You cant belittle and degrade a customer in front of 5-10 other customers about something that your employee messed up on. Accept that your employee made a mistake & fix the customers order. I will never be going back to this establishment for pizza. There are much better pizzeria's a couple of blocks away with cheaper prices & nicer people who enjoy their customer's presence.

• Kristen Walker

  star star star star star 17 May 2026

  Good pizza and prices. Good for a quick bite to eat. Staff is wonderfully friendly.

• michael anthony

  star star star star star 11 May 2026

  Best damn pizza on long island, unbelievable, no heartburn from sauce